There have been 21 government shutdowns in the U.S. since the implementation of the modern budget process in 1976, which, along with other fiscal crises, have primarily arisen from disputes between Congress and the White House over spending levels and political priorities.
Contents
- There have been 21 government shutdowns in the U.S. since the implementation of the modern budget process in 1976, which, along with other fiscal crises, have primarily arisen from disputes between Congress and the White House over spending levels and political priorities.
- Below are some of the most significant shutdowns and their impact:
The economic consequences of these crises and shutdowns have ranged from relatively minor disruptions to significant impacts on GDP growth and consumer confidence.
Reasons for Crises and Shutdowns
Disagreements that have led to government shutdowns and other fiscal crises since 1980 have generally centered on the following issues:
- Spending Levels: The most common conflict arises from a lack of agreement on the federal budget. One party, often the Republicans, advocates for spending cuts to reduce the deficit, while the other, usually the Democrats, opposes cuts to social programs or seeks increases in other areas.
- Political Priorities: On several occasions, shutdowns have been used as a negotiation tool to achieve political goals not directly related to the budget. Notable examples include disputes over funding for the Border Wall, the Affordable Care Act (Obamacare), and immigration policies.
- Debt Limits: Crises have also arisen from disagreements over raising the debt ceiling, which is the total amount of money the U.S. government can borrow to meet its existing obligations. Delaying a debt ceiling increase can bring the country to the brink of default, with serious economic consequences.
Economic Consequences
While each shutdown has a different impact depending on its duration and the economic climate at the time, there are common and recurring consequences:
- Loss of Economic Growth: Government shutdowns disrupt economic activity. The Congressional Budget Office (CBO) has estimated that shutdowns reduce GDP growth. For example, the 35-day shutdown between 2018 and 2019 reduced projected real GDP by approximately $3 billion.
- Impact on Federal Employees: Hundreds of thousands of federal employees are furloughed without pay. Although historically they have received back pay after the government reopens, the financial uncertainty affects their personal spending and morale.
- Disruption of Government Services: Many government services are suspended or reduced. This can include the closure of national parks, delays in passport and visa processing, and disruptions to small business loans and mortgage approvals.
- Uncertainty in the Private Sector: Businesses that work with the federal government, as well as the tourism sector and other industries that rely on government services, suffer economic losses. The general uncertainty can also cause businesses to delay investments and hiring.
- Damage to Confidence: Fiscal crises and shutdowns can damage national and international confidence in the United States’ ability to manage its finances. This can lead to a downgrade in the country’s credit rating, as happened in 2011 by Standard & Poor’s, which increases borrowing costs for the government and, ultimately, for taxpayers.
Below are some of the most significant shutdowns and their impact:
- 1995-1996 Shutdown: During the Clinton administration, two shutdowns lasting a total of 27 days focused on spending cuts proposed by Republicans in Congress. The estimated cost was around 0.5% of GDP.
- 2013 Shutdown: A 16-day shutdown during the Obama administration was triggered by Republican efforts to defund the Affordable Care Act. The rating agency S&P estimated it cost the economy $24 billion.
- 2018-2019 Shutdown: The longest shutdown in U.S. history lasted 35 days and centered on President Trump’s demand for funding for a wall on the Mexican border. The CBO estimated the economy lost $11 billion during the shutdown, of which $3 billion was not recovered.
Written by
El Hispano650 stories published
Writes for El Hispano Para Todos, the newspaper of the Latino community of Palm Beach and the Treasure Coast.
See all their stories →
